Any sense of danger the audience felt for the hapless assistant has now gone and they are left with a feeling of having been tricked. But not tricked in a good way, more in a here's-a-present-for-you-but-when-you-open-the-gift-it's-an-empty-box kind of way...
I have a solution to revamp these illusions and eliminate this feeling but so far none of the illusionists I've talked to are interested. I guess the status quo is good enough for them.
I wonder when someone will do a study of what people are actually thinking while watching a magic trick, moment by moment. Would be very interesting and I think very educational for magicians. (But I'm not sure they really want to know...)
Please have a look at our website: www.ScottandMuriel.com Thanks!!